So you're thinking about moving to New Jersey? Smart choice. I moved here five years ago after getting tired of NYC rents, and let me tell you – this state's got surprises. But here's the kicker: there's no single "best" place that works for everyone. Your perfect town depends entirely on what you need day-to-day. Through trial and error (and helping dozens of friends relocate), I've learned that finding the best places to live in New Jersey requires matching neighborhoods to lifestyles.
Quick reality check: Jersey gets a bad rap sometimes. Yes, there are congested highways and industrial zones. But drive 20 minutes in any direction and you'll find historic downtowns, top-ranked schools, and communities where neighbors actually know each other. The trick is knowing where to look.
What Really Matters When Choosing Your NJ Base
Forget generic lists. After interviewing dozens of residents and crunching data from state reports, these factors actually impact daily life:
- Commute Realities: That "30-minute train ride" promise? Sometimes it means 50 minutes with delays. I learned this the hard way when I first rented in Montclair.
- Hidden Costs: Property taxes vary wildly. A $600K home might carry $8k taxes in one town and $18k in another. Ouch.
- Neighborhood Vibe: Some towns roll up sidewalks at 8pm. Others have downtowns buzzing till midnight. Which are you?
- School Nuances: GreatSchools ratings don't show everything. Some districts have cutthroat competition, others focus on arts.
The Gold Standard: Our Evaluation Criteria
We rated towns using data points people genuinely care about:
| Criteria | Why It Matters | Data Sources |
|---|---|---|
| Home Price/Taxes | Actual monthly costs beyond mortgage | NJ Treasury Dept, Zillow data |
| Commute Times | Peak vs off-peak reality checks | NJ Transit, Waze congestion data |
| Safety Metrics | Violent vs property crime breakdown | FBI Uniform Crime Reports |
| School Performance | Test scores vs college placement | Niche.com, state report cards |
| Local Economy | Job growth & business openings | NJ Labor Department |
The Contenders: Top Spots for Different Lifestyles
For City Commuters: Hoboken & Jersey City
My buddy Dan pays $2,800/month for a 700 sq ft Hoboken walk-up. Steep? Sure. But his PATH train gets him to Manhattan in 18 minutes flat. Here's the tradeoff:
| Metric | Hoboken | Jersey City (Downtown) |
|---|---|---|
| Avg 1BR Rent | $3,100 | $2,900 |
| PATH to WTC | 18 min | 25 min |
| Parking Permit | $15/year (but good luck finding spots) | $50/year |
| Walk Score | 98 (Walker's Paradise) | 92 |
Personal take: Hoboken feels like a college town for adults. Great bars, but prepare for constant street festivals. Jersey City's got more diversity and those killer Manhattan views from Exchange Place.
Suburban Dream Towns: Ridgewood & Princeton
When my sister had twins, she traded Hoboken for Ridgewood. Here's why these spots dominate family searches for best places to live in northern New Jersey:
- Ridgewood: Tudor-style downtown with toy stores and bakeries. Avg home: $1.2M. Taxes hurt ($24k/year) but schools are elite.
- Princeton: Ivy League vibe permeates everything. Farmers market on Nassau Street feels straight out of a movie. Home prices start around $850k.
Watch out: Princeton's public schools are excellent, but the hyper-achiever culture stresses some kids. Ridgewood's downtown parking? A nightmare after 10am.
Hidden Gems: Collingswood & Montclair
These prove you don't need Manhattan proximity for cool factor:
Collingswood (Camden County) has a BYOB restaurant row that'd make Brooklyn jealous. My favorite: Hearthside (623 Haddon Ave) with killer cassoulet. Median home: $320k. PATCO to Philly in 15 mins.
Montclair's my personal pick for culture. The Wellmont Theater books indie bands you'd normally see in NYC. But that artsy vibe comes with congestion – I avoid Valley Road after 4pm.
| Town | Best For | Tradeoff |
|---|---|---|
| Collingswood | Foodies, budget-conscious | Limited corporate jobs |
| Montclair | Arts, diversity | High property taxes |
Crunching the Numbers: What Living Here Actually Costs
Let's get brutally honest about budgets. These figures come from actual residents:
| Town | Median Home Price | Annual Property Tax | Avg Utility Costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Princeton | $850,000 | $18,900 | $280/month |
| Hoboken | $780,000 (condo) | $9,800 | $220/month |
| Collingswood | $320,000 | $8,200 | $310/month |
| Summit | $1.1 million | $22,500 | $340/month |
That tax sting? It funds NJ's top-ranked schools and services. Still hurts writing that check though.
Getting Around: Transportation Realities
NJ Transit runs the show. After riding it daily for years, here's the unfiltered truth:
- Peak Hours: That 7:18am train from Maplewood? Gets you to Penn Station by 8:05 – if there are no "mechanical issues." Always budget 20% extra time.
- Costs: Monthly pass from Montclair to NYC: $221. From Princeton Junction: $463. Ouch factor varies.
- Driving: Route 17 is a parking lot from 7-9am. Garden State Parkway near Paramus? Avoid Fridays.
Pro tip: Look for towns with jitney services. Ridgewood's private bus gets commuters to Port Authority faster than NJ Transit for $6/ride.
Schools Beyond the Ratings
GreatSchools ratings don't show everything. After touring districts with my realtor cousin:
| District | Standout Feature | Underrated Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Millburn | #1 in state rankings | Entrepreneurship programs |
| West Windsor-Plainsboro | STEM focus | Mental health support |
| Glen Ridge | Small class sizes | Theater arts |
Watch for district lines! Living three blocks apart can mean different schools. Verify with official maps.
Your Burning Questions Answered
Where's safest for families?
Berkeley Heights and Chatham have near-zero violent crime. But "safest" depends – suburban towns have higher property crime near train stations.
Can I find affordable spots near NYC?
Look at Harrison or Kearny. Older homes near Harrison PATH start around $450k. Tradeoff: less walkable than Hoboken.
Best shore towns for year-round living?
Asbury Park's reborn with new condos (from $600k), but winters get quiet. Bay Head has charm but limited amenities off-season.
Where do young professionals go besides Hoboken?
Morristown's exploding. Iron Bar on South Street packs in crowds. Studio apartments run $1,900 vs Hoboken's $2,800.
Most overrated town?
Short Hills. Beautiful mansions, but zero downtown. You'll drive everywhere. For $2M+ homes? I expected more.
Red Flags You Won't See on Zillow
Some things only locals know:
- Flood Zones: Parts of Wayne and Little Ferry got hammered by Sandy. Check FEMA maps.
- Development Drama: Ridgewood fights over every new building. Delays are guaranteed.
- Train Noise: Homes near Montclair's Bay Street Station hear horns at 5:45am.
- Infrastructure: Jersey City's water mains break constantly. Ask about pipe ages.
Always visit at different times – Sunday morning vs Friday happy hour reveals different towns.
The Verdict: It's About Fit
After five years here? I'd pick Montclair again despite the taxes. That Saturday farmers market community feeling beats lower costs elsewhere. But your calculus differs.
Final thought: Rent before buying if possible. Neighborhoods reveal their true selves after six months. The best places to live in New Jersey aren't universal – they're personal.
Leave A Comment