Let's cut to the chase - finding truly great anime feels like digging for gold these days. Everyone's got opinions, but what actually makes the cut as a best rated anime series? I learned the hard way after wasting weekends on overhyped shows. This guide pulls from real fan ratings, streaming stats, and my own trial-and-error binges.
How We Determine True Best Rated Anime Series
Words like "best" get tossed around too easily. When I say best rated anime shows, I'm talking hard data from:
- MyAnimeList (MAL) scores from millions of users
- Crunchyroll viewership numbers
- IMDb anime rankings
- Reddit community polls
But numbers don't tell the whole story. Some shows get skewed ratings from hype trains. Remember when everyone lost their minds over that mediocre isekai last season? Exactly.
The Definitive Top Rated Anime Masterlist
After cross-referencing sources and rewatching classics, here's what genuinely deserves the best rated anime series title. These aren't just personal favorites - they're consensus home-runs.
| Anime Title | Avg Score | Genre | Why It Dominates | Where to Watch |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood | 9.2 | Action Drama | Perfect story payoff (unlike the 2003 version) | Crunchyroll, Netflix |
| Steins;Gate | 9.1 | Sci-Fi Thriller | Mind-bending time travel done right | Hulu, Funimation |
| Attack on Titan | 8.9 | Dark Fantasy Action | Unmatched world-building depth | Crunchyroll, Hulu |
| Hunter x Hunter (2011) | 9.0 | Adventure Battle | Evolution of shonen tropes | Netflix, HBO Max |
| Your Lie in April | 8.7 | Romance Drama | Emotional storytelling with music | Crunchyroll, Netflix |
Notice something? These best rated anime series share common DNA: airtight plotting, character development that actually matters, and zero filler. Brotherhood sticks the landing because every episode drives toward the finale - no beach episodes here.
Best Rated Anime Series By Genre
Generic rankings are useless when you hate mecha but love horror. Here's the real meat - best rated anime series sorted by what you actually enjoy.
Mind-Bending Sci-Fi & Psychological
For those who want their brains scrambled:
| Anime | Conce pt | Watch If You Like |
|---|---|---|
| Steins;Gate | Time travel consequences | Dark, Christopher Nolan films |
| Psycho-Pass | Dystopian crime prediction | Blade Runner vibes |
| Made in Abyss | Mysterious deadly chasm | Body horror + adventure |
Emotional Gut-Punch Dramas
Bring tissues territory:
- Violet Evergarden (Netflix): War veteran learns emotions through letters. Animation will ruin other shows for you
- Clannad: After Story (HIDIVE): Second season destroys souls. Skip if you dislike slow burns
- A Silent Voice (Netflix movie): Bullying and redemption arc. Heavy but essential
Action-Packed Battle Series
When you just want epic fights:
| Anime | Battle System | Standout Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Demon Slayer | Sword breathing techniques | Ufotable's god-tier animation |
| Jujutsu Kaisen | Cursed energy manipulation | Bleach-level fights with better pacing |
| One Punch Man S1 | Parody superhero powers | Madhouse's sakuga masterpiece |
Underrated Gems That Deserve More Love
Some best rated anime series never hit mainstream. Criminal omissions:
- Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju (Crunchyroll): Period drama about theatrical storytelling. Slow burn perfection
- Mushishi (Hulu): Supernatural vignettes with zen atmosphere. Perfect before bed
- Land of the Lustrous (Amazon Prime): CGI done right. Philosophical gem people
Mushishi is my go-to when anime burnout hits. Each episode stands alone - no cliffhangers, just pure atmosphere. Like Studio Ghibli meets Twilight Zone.
Where to Legally Stream Best Rated Anime
Finding these legally matters - pirated sites often have malware and terrible subs. Trust me, I learned after my laptop got crypto-mined in 2018.
| Service | Price/Month | Best For | Library Depth |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crunchyroll | $7.99 (ads) - $14.99 | Simulcasts, classics | Industry leader |
| Netflix | $6.99 - $19.99 | Originals, films | Growing but selective |
| HIDIVE | $4.99 | Niche classics | Smaller but curated |
Your Best Rated Anime Questions Answered
What's the single highest rated anime ever?
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood consistently tops charts. MAL score: 9.25 from 2M+ users. It's the gold standard for tight plotting.
Do movie anime count as "series"?
For this guide? No - we're sticking to multi-episode runs. But standalone films like Spirited Away or Your Name would dominate any movie list.
Why isn't [My Favorite] on these lists?
Personal taste varies wildly. Darling in the Franxx has passionate fans, but that messy second half tanked its ratings. And yes - I think Death Note's ending hurts it too.
Can new anime break into best rated territory?
Absolutely. Chainsaw Man exploded in 2022 and will likely climb. But classics stay for good reason - they've survived years of scrutiny.
Final Reality Check
Chasing best rated anime series lists can become paralysis by analysis. My rule? Watch episode 1 of 3 highly-rated shows that interest you. Drop anything that doesn't grab you by episode 3 - life's too short.
The true magic happens when you find that unexpected show that wasn't on any list. Mine was Odd Taxi - a weird anthropomorphic thriller that became my 2021 obsession. Sometimes the real best rated anime is the one that speaks directly to you.
Leave A Comment