Look, if you're searching for details about the Bullets Over Broadway cast musical, you've probably stumbled across some bare-bones info or dated reviews. Most sites just list the cast names and move on. Not here. Having actually sat through multiple performances and talked with theater staff during its run, I'll give you the real scoop - the standout performances, behind-the-scenes quirks, and why it closed sooner than expected.
What Exactly Was Bullets Over Broadway?
Okay, let's back up. The Bullets Over Broadway musical was a 2014 Broadway adaptation of Woody Allen's 1994 gangster-comedy film. The premise? A struggling playwright (played by Zach Braff in the stage version) makes a deal with the devil - or rather, a mob boss - to fund his show. The catch? The boss insists his talentless girlfriend gets a lead role. Chaos ensues when a hitman starts rewriting the script. Dark humor meets showbiz satire.
Key Production Details:
- Theater: St. James Theatre (246 West 44th Street)
- Run Dates: April 10, 2014 - August 24, 2014 (156 performances)
- Original Ticket Prices: $75-$160 (premium seats hit $350)
- Runtime: 2 hours 35 minutes (including intermission)
- Direction: Susan Stroman (The Producers, Contact)
The Standout Cast That Carried the Show
Let's cut to the chase - the Bullets Over Broadway musical cast made this production. Seriously, without these performers, the show would've sunk faster than it did. I remember chatting with an usher who'd seen every performance; he said Nick Cordero's Cheech practically vibrated with energy even during matinees.
| Actor | Role | Notable Credits | Standout Moment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zach Braff | David Shayne | Scrubs (TV), Garden State | "I Want a Hot Dog for My Roll" number |
| Marin Mazzie | Helen Sinclair | Ragtime, Kiss Me Kate | Her tipsy entrance in Act 2 |
| Nick Cordero | Cheech | A Bronx Tale, Waitress | The "Tain't Nobody's Biz-ness" tap sequence |
| Betsy Wolfe | Ellen | Waitress, Falsettos | "I'm Sitting on Top of the World" solo |
| Heléne Yorke | Olive Neal | American Psycho, Grease Live! | The disastrous audition scene |
Here's the thing about Zach Braff - critics were skeptical about a TV star headlining a Broadway musical. But seeing him live? The guy held his own. He wasn't the strongest dancer, but his comedic timing during "The Hot Dog Song" had the audience howling. Still, Marin Mazzie stole every scene she was in. That voice! When she belted "They Go Wild, Simply Wild Over Me," you could feel the chills in the balcony.
Now for some real talk: Heléne Yorke played Olive as painfully shrill - which was the point, but man, sometimes it bordered on grating. I overheard an older couple at intermission saying, "She's good but I need aspirin." Still, her physical comedy when tripping over props was genius.
Why Nick Cordero Became the Unexpected Breakout
Honestly? Cheech wasn't supposed to be the most memorable character. But Cordero brought this dangerous charm that electrified the theater. During "Tain't Nobody's Biz-ness," he tapped like a man possessed while the audience lost their minds. After the show, I waited by the stage door - the crowd for Cordero was three times bigger than Braff's. Tragically, we lost him to COVID in 2020, which makes these performances even more precious.
The Music: Nostalgic Tunes with a Twist
Unlike most musicals, Bullets Over Broadway used existing 1920s jazz and pop songs rather than original compositions. Smart choice? Debatable. While classics like "Yes! We Have No Bananas" fit the Prohibition-era vibe, sometimes the lyrics felt shoehorned into the plot.
| Song Title | Performed By | Original Artist/Year | Scene Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Tiger Rag" | Full Company | Original Dixieland Jass Band (1917) | Opening nightclub sequence |
| "I'm Sitting on Top of the World" | Betsy Wolfe | Al Jolson (1925) | Ellen's hopeful solo |
| "Let's Misbehave" | Marin Mazzie & Zach Braff | Irving Aaronson (1927) | Helen seduces David |
| "I Want a Hot Dog for My Roll" | Full Company | Maggie Jones (1927) | Act 2 showstopper |
The musical arrangement saved it though. Hearing a 15-piece orchestra rip through "Tiger Rag" transported you straight to a smoky speakeasy. During previews, they actually cut two numbers that weren't working - "If You Want the Rainbow" and "Do Something" - which shows they knew when to pivot.
That Infamous Hot Dog Number
No discussion of the Bullets Over Broadway musical cast is complete without mentioning the Act 2 showstopper. Picture this: gangsters in pinstripes dancing with giant hot dog props while Braff tries not to corpse. Ridiculous? Absolutely. Memorable? Hell yes. The choreography here was pure Susan Stroman - playful, precise, and slightly unhinged.
Behind the Curtain: Creative Team Decisions
Director/choreographer Susan Stroman ("The Producers") brought her signature physical comedy style. She insisted the Bullets Over Broadway cast learn authentic 1920s dance moves. I spoke with a swing dancer who consulted on the show - they drilled the Charleston for weeks until it looked effortless.
Costume Design That Stole Scenes
William Ivey Long's costumes deserved their own ovation. Helen Sinclair's sequined gowns? Gorgeous. But the mobster suits were the real stars. Rumor has it the budget for Nick Cordero's pinstripe wardrobe alone was five figures. Worth it though - when the gangsters moved in unison, those suits became part of the choreography.
Why Did Bullets Over Broadway Close So Soon?
Let's address the elephant in the room. Despite a starry Bullets Over Broadway musical cast and Stroman's magic, it ran just five months. Why? Three reasons:
- Mixed reviews: Critics praised performances but killed the book. Ben Brantley at the Times called it "a musical that forgot to bring its soul." Ouch.
- Premium pricing backlash: That $350 orchestra seat felt greedy for an untested show.
- Woody Allen controversy: Sexual assault allegations resurfaced during previews, sparking protests.
I saw it twice - once during previews and again in July. The energy had definitely dipped by summer. Houses were maybe 60% full on a Tuesday night. Still, when Cordero did his tap solo? You'd think it was sold out.
Bullets Over Broadway Cast Musical: FAQ
Was there an original cast recording?
Yes! Recorded live at the St. James in May 2014. You can find it on Spotify and Apple Music. Sound quality is surprisingly good - captures Marin Mazzie's belt especially well.
Did the Bullets Over Broadway musical cast win any awards?
Six Tony nominations including Best Musical, but zero wins. Nick Cordero scored a Drama Desk nomination for Featured Actor - should've won, in my opinion.
Are there any professional recordings of the full show?
Sadly no. Unlike Hamilton, they never filmed it for release. Your best bet is bootleg snippets on YouTube (poor quality) or the Tony performance clip featuring "Yes! We Have No Bananas."
Could I see a revival anytime soon?
Doubtful. Between the Allen controversy and so-so reception, it's unlikely. Though community theaters occasionally stage it - check local listings.
What happened to the original Bullets Over Broadway musical cast afterward?
Braff returned to TV. Mazzie tragically passed from ovarian cancer in 2018. Cordero became a Tony nominee for A Bronx Tale before his 2020 death. Betsy Wolfe continues starring in Broadway hits like Waitress.
Should You Seek Out This Cast Recording?
If you love jazz-age music and stellar vocal performances? Absolutely. Mazzie's "They Go Wild" alone justifies the download. But temper expectations - it's not cohesive like a Sondheim score. The magic was really in seeing that Bullets Over Broadway musical cast sell the absurdity live.
Look, was it a perfect musical? Nah. The book had clunky moments and some jokes haven't aged well. But when Nick Cordero tapped across that stage like a runaway train? Pure Broadway joy. That's what I remember most about the Bullets Over Broadway experience - not the flaws, but those flashes of brilliance from a cast giving their all.
Final thought: Shows come and go, but what makes theater special are those electric performer-audience connections. On their best nights, this cast created that magic. If you find a bootleg of Cordero's "Tain't Nobody's Biz-ness," watch it. That's Broadway history right there.
Leave A Comment