You know what's wild? Growing up, my grandpa never talked about Vietnam. Not once. Then last year, I found his old letters from Da Nang stuffed in a shoebox. That got me digging into what those presidents were really thinking during that mess. Turns out, understanding the president during Vietnam conflict isn't just about dates and policies - it's about human drama on a global scale.
The Unfolding Quagmire
Let's be real - Vietnam didn't suddenly explode. It brewed slowly like bad coffee. When Eisenhower took office in '53, Vietnam was already simmering. The French were getting their butts kicked at Dien Bien Phu. Ike saw dominoes - you know, that theory where one country falls to communism and others follow? He sent advisors and cash to South Vietnam. Not troops yet. Just a few hundred guys in suits teaching them how to fight. Funny how things escalate, right?
By 1960, we had about 900 "advisors" there. Then came Kennedy...
JFK's Tightrope Walk
Kennedy inherited a mess. The Bay of Pigs fiasco just happened. Now Vietnam's leader Diem was losing control. JFK increased advisors to 16,000 but refused combat troops. He famously told Cronkite: "In the final analysis, it's their war." But then he greenlit the coup against Diem in November '63. Three weeks later, Kennedy was dead. What if he'd lived? We'll never know that alternate timeline.
Here's something they don't teach in school - Kennedy actually signed NSAM 263 to withdraw 1,000 troops by end of '63. Found that declassified doc in National Archives last year. Makes you question everything.
LBJ's Point of No Return
Johnson took over and things got real. Gulf of Tonkin incident happens August '64 - two murky attacks on US ships. LBJ gets Congress to pass the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution. It's basically a blank check for war. Then Operation Rolling Thunder starts - nonstop bombing of North Vietnam. By '65, he's sending combat troops. Lots of them.
What's fascinating? Johnson knew it was a trap. He told his National Security Advisor: "I don't think it's worth fighting for and I don't think we can get out." But he kept escalating anyway. The pressures of politics, man - they warp everything.
| President | Years | Troop Deployment Start | Peak Troop Levels | Key Military Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eisenhower | 1953-1961 | ~900 advisors | 3,200 | Financial/material aid only |
| Kennedy | 1961-1963 | 16,000 | 16,500 | Strategic Hamlet Program |
| Johnson | 1963-1969 | 23,000 combat troops | 548,000 (1968) | Operation Rolling Thunder |
| Nixon | 1969-1974 | 540,000 | 156,800 (1972) | Cambodia bombings |
| Ford | 1974-1975 | ~50,000 | Evacuation teams | Fall of Saigon |
Seeing those numbers still shocks me. Half a million kids in jungle hell. And for what? That's the question that haunted Johnson till he died.
The Turning Points Nobody Talks About
Everyone knows Tet Offensive changed things. But what about the silent killers? Like how:
- The draft system favored college kids - rich man's war, poor man's fight as they said
- Fragging became a thing - soldiers killing their own officers
- Drug use was rampant - estimated 30% of troops addicted to heroin by '71
Nixon's Gambit
Enter Nixon promising "peace with honor." He starts Vietnamization - handing the war back to South Vietnam while withdrawing US troops. Sounds smart, right? But then he secretly bombs Cambodia for 14 months. When it leaked, campuses exploded. Kent State happened. Four dead students.
That moment when you realize your peace president is widening the war.
Nixon eventually gets the Paris Peace Accords signed in '73. US prisoners come home. But the agreement was Swiss cheese - North Vietnam just waited us out. Still, Nixon got credit for "ending" America's longest war. Until Watergate drowned his legacy.
Ford's Impossible Hand
Gerald Ford had the worst job - presiding during the collapse. By April '75, North Vietnamese tanks are rolling toward Saigon. Ford begs Congress for $722 million in emergency aid for South Vietnam. They say no. The images of helicopters evacuating people from rooftops? That's Ford's presidency defining moment.
| President | Decision Style | Key Advisors | Biggest Criticism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eisenhower | Cautious containment | Dulles brothers | Launched domino theory |
| Kennedy | Micromanager | McNamara, Bundy | Approved Diem coup |
| Johnson | Consensus-seeker | "Tuesday Lunch Group" | Escalated without exit plan |
| Nixon | Secretive unilateral | Kissinger, Haig | Bombed Cambodia illegally |
| Ford | Damage control | Kissinger, Scowcroft | Couldn't secure evacuation funds |
My professor at Georgetown called it "the tragedy of good intentions." Each president during Vietnam conflict thought they were preventing worse outcomes. Eisenhower feared dominoes. JFK feared looking weak after Bay of Pigs. LBJ feared another "who lost China?" moment. Nixon feared humiliation. Ford just tried to save lives amid the wreckage.
What Really Bothered Soldiers On The Ground
Talk to vets and you hear things textbooks miss. Like how:
- Rules of engagement changed constantly - couldn't shoot unless shot at first
- Body count became the metric of success - led to inflated numbers
- Rotation policy meant units constantly lost experienced members
I remember my neighbor Tom, a Marine at Khe Sanh, telling me: "We weren't fighting for democracy. We were fighting for the guy next to us. The politics? That was Washington's circus."
Burning Questions About Vietnam Conflict Presidents
Who was the main president during Vietnam War?
Technically five presidents held office during the conflict. But Johnson oversaw the massive escalation (1965-1968) - so he's most associated with the war's peak. Nixon gets credit for withdrawal but widened the war secretly first.
Why did presidents keep escalating Vietnam?
Fear mostly. Fear of looking weak. Fear of communism spreading. Fear of electoral backlash. Johnson privately called Vietnam "that bitch of a war" but feared impeachment if he "lost" it. The Cold War mindset trapped them all.
How did each president affect draft policies?
- Kennedy: Expanded draft calls quietly
- Johnson: Ended student deferments (massive protests)
- Nixon: Instituted draft lottery system (fairer but unpopular)
- Ford: Ended draft in 1975
What critical mistakes did presidents make?
Eisenhower backing Diem. Kennedy approving the coup. Johnson micromanaging bombing targets. Nixon's secret Cambodia bombing. Ford's failure to secure evacuation funds. Hindsight's brutal, isn't it?
The Ghosts That Haunted Them
Each president carried Vietnam differently. Eisenhower retired peacefully but his domino theory shaped decades of policy. Kennedy's assassination froze his record in time - we debate what might've been. Johnson died bitter four years after leaving office, Vietnam destroying his Great Society dreams. Nixon resigned over Watergate but always claimed Vietnam peace as his triumph. Ford lived longest, pardoning Nixon but never escaping those Saigon rooftop images.
Walking through the Vietnam Memorial Wall at night changes you. All 58,000 names under your fingertips. Makes you wonder - how many stemmed from a single bad decision by a president during Vietnam conflict? Heavy stuff.
Presidential Legacies in the Mud
History's verdict is harsh. Eisenhower gets partial pass as "pre-war." Kennedy's aura survives despite his early escalation. Johnson's domestic achievements are overshadowed by Vietnam. Nixon's diplomatic wins are tainted by Cambodia and Watergate. Ford is remembered for the fall he couldn't prevent.
| President | Start of Term Approval | Lowest Vietnam-Era Rating | Major Approval Trigger |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eisenhower | 68% | 49% (recession) | Generally high throughout |
| Kennedy | 72% | 56% (Bay of Pigs) | Cuban Missile Crisis rebound |
| Johnson | 78% (after JFK death) | 35% (Tet Offensive) | Civil Rights Act boost |
| Nixon | 62% | 24% (Watergate) | China visit peak (68%) |
| Ford | 71% (post-pardon drop) | 37% (inflation crisis) | Post-evacuation sympathy |
Notice how Johnson's approval cut in half during his term? That's the Vietnam toll right there. Nixon actually had decent ratings until Watergate blew up. Shows foreign policy doesn't always sink presidents - it's the coverups that kill them.
The Documents That Changed Everything
Some papers just rewrite history:
- Pentagon Papers (1971): Revealed systematic lying by multiple administrations
- NSAM 263 (JFK): Planned Vietnam withdrawal (disputed)
- Gulf of Tonkin Resolution (1964): Gave LBJ war powers
Reading the Pentagon Papers today... wow. The casual deception. McNamara admitting by '67 the war was unwinnable. Yet bombing continued. Makes you question all government narratives.
Did Any President Handle Vietnam Well?
Honest answer? No. They all made catastrophic errors. Eisenhower planted seeds. Kennedy watered them. Johnson harvested thorns. Nixon burned the field. Ford buried the ashes. Each president during Vietnam conflict became prisoner of the last guy's mistakes.
But here's what gets me - they weren't cartoon villains. They genuinely believed they were protecting America. That's the scary part. Smart people making disastrous calls with good intentions.
My two cents? The presidency during Vietnam conflict became a poison chalice. Once we committed prestige instead of just interests, there was no graceful exit. That's the real lesson for future wars. Pride costs more than dollars or bullets.
So next time someone simplifies Vietnam to "bad presidents" or "anti-war heroes," remember the complexity. No black and white - just endless gray. Like my grandpa finally told me last Veterans Day: "We were all just trying to survive, kid. Some succeeded. Some didn't. Presidents included."
Leave A Comment